A rock and a hard place: Port Adelaide unfazed by critics of succession plan

Power assistant coach Josh Carr addressed the media ahead of the clubโ€™s Round 2 clash against Richmond.

Aidan Cellini
913

Port Adelaide assistant coach Josh Carr says the club would receive scrutiny regardless of whether they announced their succession plan ahead of the 2025 season.

Carr will take over from long-time standing coach Ken Hinkley at the completion of the current campaign, which began with a 91-point drubbing against Collingwood in Round 1.

Critics from far and wide have added their two cents, suggesting that if the Power's top dogs don't think Hinkley is their man they should've parted ways following last year's preliminary final loss.

 Saturday, March 22 
Port Adel WON BY 72 POINTS
Adelaide Oval
PORT   
140
FT
68
   RICH

However, Carr, speaking on Friday, said that it wouldn't matter what decision the Alberton club made regarding the coaching configuration, the criticism would always come for the contending club, especially after a poor performance.

"You can look at all aspects of that and think about if it's not announced, what that looks like, and what it has been in previous years," Carr said, according to Channel 7.

"I have probably been asked a lot more questions in previous years than what I have been asked this year so there's always a distraction, no matter what.

"You guys (media) have a job to do which is important and you have got to dig and make news and ... do whatever you have to do."

Heading into Round 2 and a chance to play in front of the home crowd at Adelaide Oval against a youthful Richmond, the Power have an opportunity to respond, like they've done consistently in Hinkley's tenure.

Carr was questioned, given the coaching handover, whether there was confusion over who was calling the shots, to which he responded: "I'm really comfortable with understanding what my role is and what our role is at this footy club and where we're at.

"So when there's noise outside, it doesn't bother me and I don't think it bothers anyone internally, because we understand what our jobs are.

"Externally, the pressure comes on and you like to think that's when we do our best work."

Port Adelaide has only made one change for Saturday's clash against the Tigers, debuting draftee Christian Moraes whilst swinging the axe on forward-turned-defender Jeremy Finlayson.

The former Giant has been forced down back due to injuries to key personnel, but the left-field solution lasted only four quarters after Collingwood's three talls combined for 10 goals.

"It's probably just felt like he's not there as far as the position goes and there were aspects of his game last weekend that we weren't happy with," Carr said.

"Jeremy knows what (he needs to work on). He's aware of it. I don't think I need to make that public.

"So, the accountability aspect is all over the ground, and we're not highlighting one person just because he's been omitted from the team."

As for the Power's Pick 38 in the 2024 National Draft, the silky midfielder could surprise a few with what he can produce.

"He's elite with his work rate, his contest to contest (work). Obviously, it's a surprise externally," Carr said.

"Internally, he was around the mark, and you know, we feel it is important to reward form at this stage.

"His attention to detail on his game is just super so his want to play AFL footy is nearly some of the strongest that I've seen."