With Brownlow Medal night just a few sleeps away, the footy world awaits to see who will take home the most prestigious award in our code.

Will Marcus Bontempelli finally claim that elusive title? Is it Nick Daicos' time to shine? Surely Lachie Neale hasn't secured a third... right?

We can only craft up our greatest predictions and punts before the big night, but in the meantime, we might as well declare a fantasy winner.

Most footy fans will be familiar with theย Heraldย Sun's fantasy AFL game 'SuperCoach'.

This game ranks players according to a unique database of statistical production, rewarding players for their prolific ability in the most impactful categories: goals, contested marks, intercepts, and assists.

While not perfect, the highest SuperCoach scorers in games are often the most impactful players on the ground. It's not perfect, sometimes inflating the impact of safe-kicking rebound defenders or high-volume tap ruckman, but it holds up well nonetheless.

MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA - JUNE 12: Max Gawn of the Demons and Darcy Cameron of the Magpies compete in a ruck contest during the 2023 AFL Round 13 match between the Melbourne Demons and the Collingwood Magpies at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on June 12, 2023 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Michael Willson/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

So, we've gone through the top SuperCoach scorers from each home & away match in 2024, ranking the three best and tallying up the final votes to decide the winner.

For tied scores, we give the nod to the player with the higher AFL Fantasy score.

The method has it's flaws - one game sees St Kilda have all three vote-getters in an 85-point trouncing at the hands of Brisbane.

But the final results produce a plausible list of contenders, with a riveting battle up the top.

Let's get straight into the winner/s!

FINAL LEADERBOARD

1 - Lachie Neale (25)
1 - Max Gawn (25)
1 - Marcus Bontempelli (25)
2 - Nick Daicos (24)
3 - Zach Merrett (22)
4 - Luke Ryan (21)
4 - Noah Anderson (21)
5 - Caleb Serong (20)
5 - Tristan Xerri (20)
5 - Zak Butters (20)

6 - Rowan Marshall (19)
7 - Toby Nankervis (17)
8 - Dayne Zorko (16)
8 - Patrick Cripps (16)
8 - Andrew Brayshaw (16)
8 - Isaac Heeney (16)
9 - Jordan Dawson (15)
9 - Darcy Cameron (15)
9 - Matt Rowell (15)
9 - Lachie Whitfield (15)
9 - Harry Sheezel (15)
9 - Adam Treloar (15)
10 - Nic Newman (14)

Tom Green (13)
Jack Sinclair (13)
Jack Steele (13)
Sam Walsh (12)
Tom De Koning (12)
Nic Martin (12)
Jordan Clark (12)
Tim English (12)
Josh Dunkley (11)
Sam Flanders (11)
Dylan Moore (11)
Luke Davies-Uniacke (11)
Brodie Grundy (11)
Tom Stewart (10)
Kieren Briggs (10)
Jai Newcombe (10)
James Sicily (10)
Ollie Wines (10)
Errol Gulden (10)
Bailey Dale (10)

Back
Next

Round 5

Melbourne (60 vs 82) Brisbane

  • 3 votes - Max Gawn (138) - MELB
  • 2 votes - Cam Rayner (137) - BRIS
  • 1 vote - Josh Dunkley (122) - BRIS

Western Bulldogs (67 vs 96) Essendon

GWS (80 vs 79) St Kilda

  • 3 votes - Jack Steele (143) - STK
  • 2 votes - Brad Hill (132) - STK
  • 1 vote - Lachie Ash (122) - GWS

Carlton (98 vs 100) Adelaide

Gold Coast (109 vs 56) Hawthorn

Port Adelaide (66 vs 63) Fremantle

  • 3 votes - Luke Ryan (145) - FRE
  • 2 votes - Josh Treacy (135) - FRE
  • 1 vote - Zak Butters (130) - PA

Geelong (139 vs 64) North Melbourne

West Coast (109 vs 70) Richmond

Back
Next