GWS Giants

Mr. Meanwhile: Why the Giants can’t bank on a McVeigh spike

New brooms are said to sweep clean, but is history actually on ‘Spike’s side?

Published by
Ed Carmine

It has long been acknowledged that coaching athletes at the elite level is just about the toughest job outside of sweeping sewers or removing roadkill for a dollar.

Not only is your performance critiqued to well outside the bounds of sanity, but in a zero-sum game, if the wins don't outweigh the losses and cups aren't added to cabinets, any and all efforts made are deemed to be insufficient.

No wonder the vast majority of men at the helm across the league appear so content to cultivate grey hairs.

With so many hours consumed building blueprints, altering line-ups and fretting over future fixtures, the throws of the caper have consumed the minds of many and remained undefeated against all who have dared to lead since before the first Sherrin was ever stitched.

However, since transitioning sharply from a pass-time played out by part-timers to the full-time, full-on professional era, these same stewards that were previously left to fly solo now have more deputies at their disposal than Stormin' Norman Schwarzkopf.

Although each of the competition's 18 head coaches have fleets of assistants to help out with duties both on the training track and on game day, it is this same collective of offsiders that harbour dreams to hold high office and often end up in the hot seat once the daggers are drawn.

And with the Giants shuffling their coaching deck ahead of their Round 9 loss to Carlton, Mark McVeigh was named the latest lieutenant to earn his stripes.

Following Leon Cameron's exit after eight seasons and change as the head honcho of the orange and charcoal franchise, McVeigh's elevation from assistant to interim coach will see him become just the third name since the Giants' inception to hold the reigns in the Harbour City's west.

With an inauspicious 2-9 start to the 2022 season seeing the league's youngest side slide outside of finals contention in the eyes of most punters and pundits, the role before the former Bomber should, realistically, come with less strain than was shackled to Cameron.

Add in the routinely trotted-out cliché that an interim coach's broom is a lock to sweep clean, and common consensus will likely have the Giants' minute fanbase expecting a Round 10 spike under 'Spike'.

Strangely, commentators and supporters seem keen to continue pressing the almost superstitious theory that stand-in coaching options actually have a greater chance of winning games than the names that were previously hired on a full-time basis.

Yet, when actually put to the test, this belief that interim coaches are sureties to claim victory in their first game calling the shots actually falls flatter than many would first believe.

MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA - APRIL 16: Leon Cameron, Senior Coach of the Giants addresses his players during the 2022 AFL Round 05 match between the Melbourne Demons and the GWS Giants at the Melbourne Cricket Ground on April 16, 2022 In Melbourne, Australia. (Photo by Dylan Burns/AFL Photos via Getty Images)

Since the dawn of the 21st century, 24 assistant coaches have taken on the role of senior coach the week after their former boss bit the dust.

And in spite of the routinely put forth platitude that a first-up win can be banked on, this collective of next men up have only ever tasted victory on 11 occasions for a winning percentage of just a tick over 45.

From Ben Allan taking over Damien Drum's unenviable job of leading the Dockers in 2001, to dual Brownlow medallist Robert Harvey's seven-game stint steering the Magpies' sinking ship, these assistants thrown to the wolves have actually been more prone to dropping points rather than winning them.

Season Club Outgoing Coach Interim Coach Round Opponent Result Margin
2001 Fremantle Damien Drum Ben Allan 10 Richmond L 38
St Kilda Malcolm Blight Grant Thomas 16 Western Bulldogs L 34
2002 Sydney Rodney Eade Paul Roos 13 Fremantle W 77
Western Bulldogs Terry Wallace Peter Rohde 22 Collingwood W 41
2007 Melbourne Neale Daniher Mark Riley 14 Carlton W 23
Fremantle Chris Connolly Mark Harvey 16 Adelaide W 25
Carlton Denis Pagan Brett Ratten 17 St Kilda L 10
2008 Richmond Terry Wallace Jade Rawlings 12 West Coast W 15
North Melbourne Dani Laidley Darren Crocker 13 Western Bulldogs L 22
2010 Port Adelaide Mark Williams Matthew Primus 16 Western Bulldogs L 36
2011 Adelaide Neil Craig Mark Bickley 19 Port Adelaide W 32
Melbourne Dean Bailey Todd Viney 20 Carlton L 76
Western Bulldogs Rodney Eade Paul Williams 22 Port Adelaide W 60
2012 Port Adelaide Matthew Primus Garry Hocking 20 Hawthorn L 72
2013 Melbourne Mark Neeld Neil Craig 13 St Kilda L 35
Brisbane Michael Voss Mark Harvey 21 GWS W 60
2015 Carlton Michael Malthouse John Barker 9 Sydney L 60
Essendon James Hird Matthew Egan 21 Gold Coast L 2
2017 Gold Coast Rodney Eade Dean Solomon 21 Brisbane L 58
2019 North Melbourne Brad Scott Rhyce Shaw 11 Richmond W 37
Carlton Brendan Bolton David Teague 12 Brisbane W 15
St Kilda Alan Richardson Brett Ratten 18 Western Bulldogs W 27
Fremantle Ross Lyon David Hale 23 Port Adelaide L 43
2021 Collingwood Nathan Buckley Robert Harvey 15 Fremantle L 12

 

While truth has often escaped stories that continue to be bandied around league circles, the dented notion that change is enough to claim wins is one that McVeigh isn't buying, despite offering more than just a few trusted truisms of his own.

“My sole focus is just week to week at the moment," the 232-game Don told the media on Friday morning.

“My job right now is to stabilise everyone in the football department and make sure that we’re building in the right direction."

And though prompted for his position beyond Sunday's final siren at the Showgrounds, the bearded stand-in's bat remained equally as straight.

“Whatever happens at the end of the year, we’ve got to be in a position where we finish off really well. Where that leads, I don’t know."

Despite an inability to tap into their previous season's form that took them to the semi-final weekend, those who have studied GWS' fixture list will contend that McVeigh has just about the easiest first pitch to swing at, with his Giants set to host the plucked Eagles this Sunday.

This same group of footy pragmatists is also sure to raise the fact that Brett Ratten's inability to rouse the Blues towards the end of the 2007 season will have no bearing on the outcome of 'Spike's first class in session.

Though correct, even if McVeigh and his brigade of ex-Bombers in the coaching box can drive Leon Cameron's second-hand Lamborghini across the line this weekend, it won't be enough to breathe life into one of the most tired maxims still attached to the code.

Still, if GWS can ward off the wounded westerners in what is already a dead rubber in May, removalists and sweepers can bet their bottom dollar that unchecked mouthpieces will still be willing to stoke the flames of a truly truthless statement.

And even if the Giants do surrender the points, history suggests that the same saying will inevitably be wheeled out the next time the senior coaching fraternity loses another member.

Published by
Ed Carmine